Haydn Chilcott’s critique of “The ‘Legend’ Bill Edwards’ shop” in Oxford, while insightful, raises some important questions. Chilcott laments the shop’s perceived lack of originality, but overlooks its historical significance as a testament to Oxford’s sporting heritage. The shop’s preservation of Edwards’ legacy, while not necessarily cutting-edge, serves a valuable purpose in honoring a legendary figure in the local sporting community. Additionally, while Chilcott argues that the shop’s merchandise may not be to everyone’s taste, it remains a popular destination for those seeking memorabilia and souvenirs of the university’s sporting prowess.